Part of: Assignment Desk Works, LLC v. Alexis Berg · Musgrave v. Mace (2:25-cv-01823-RMG) · Litigation Overview & Court-Filing Index
Prosecutors drop charge against man who Rep. Nancy Mace accused of assaulting her at the Capitol
Prosecutors dropped the misdemeanor assault charge against foster-care advocate James McIntyre, whom Mace had accused of 'physically accosting' her at a December 2024 Capitol event. Three eyewitnesses said McIntyre had simply shaken her hand. The dismissal drew wide coverage, which characterized the charge's collapse as undercutting Mace's account.
"I filed charges, and they were inexplicably ignored. But I will not be. I will not back down.", Rep. Nancy Mace, statement
NBC News reported on April 2, 2025 that federal prosecutors had dropped the misdemeanor assault charge against James McIntyre, a foster-care advocate from Illinois who Mace had accused of "physically accosting" her at a Capitol event in December 2024. The prosecution's decision not to proceed came after three eyewitnesses described the interaction as a handshake and a request that Mace support transgender youth, not a physical assault.
McIntyre, who had been arrested and briefly jailed on Mace's account, responded directly to the dismissal:
"By falsely accusing me of a violent crime and having me jailed, Congresswoman Mace demonstrated her desire to criminalize anyone who advocates for the needs of our trans youth.", James McIntyre, as reported by CNN companion piece
Mace did not accept the dismissal as the end of the matter, issuing a statement that framed prosecutors as having failed her and signaling she intended to continue pressing her account. She disputes that her characterization of the incident was false.
The dropped charge followed earlier reporting by The New Republic and HuffPost in which multiple eyewitnesses described the encounter as a routine handshake. Mace had responded to that coverage in December 2024 by threatening defamation suits against media outlets that questioned her account.
Related coverage
Read next
March 14, 2025 · DispatchUS Rep. Nancy Mace sued for libel and defamation after making public accusations of abuse
Brian Musgrave, one of the four men Mace accused by name in her February 2025 House floor speech, filed a federal defamation and libel suit against her. The case was ultimately dismissed as to floor-speech claims under the Speech or Debate Clause, though the judge left open whether Mace's social-media statements were protected. All allegations are contested; Mace denied wrongdoing.
March 10, 2025 · DispatchExclusive: Man accused as 'predator' by Rep. Nancy Mace breaks his silence
In an exclusive interview with CNN national correspondent Randi Kaye, aired the evening of March 10, 2025 as a segment on 'Anderson Cooper 360°', Brian Musgrave, one of the four men Rep. Nancy Mace named in her House floor speech, denied her allegations on camera: 'Absolutely not. No, no.' Mace's allegations are contested and unproven; the dispute is the subject of ongoing civil litigation.
February 11, 2025 · DispatchRep. Nancy Mace details accusations of rape and sexual abuse in a speech from the House floor
Mace used a 50-plus-minute House floor speech to accuse four named men, including her ex-fiancé Patrick Bryant, of rape, sex trafficking, and other crimes. All four men categorically denied the allegations to NBC. The speech triggered multiple defamation lawsuits and is central to ongoing litigation; all allegations are contested and unproven.