Part of: Mace vs. the Solicitor: the campaign against the prosecutor in her own cases (2025) · Musgrave v. Mace (2:25-cv-01823-RMG) · 2026 Governor Campaign
'Thank God He Got the Justice He Deserved': Nancy Mace on Brian Banks, and What Prosecutors Wrote About Brian Musgrave
On Nov. 12, 2026, Rep. Nancy Mace replied to a thread about Brian Banks, the Long Beach, Calif., football star who served five years in prison for a rape he did not commit: 'That gave me chills. Thank god he got the justice he deserved. Sweet justice.' The post names no one else. On Feb. 11, 2025, the day after she named Brian Musgrave of Fort Mill, S.C., on the House floor, she wrote that 'if there is no evidence, there would be no investigation.' A federal court dismissed his defamation suit on immunity without ruling on whether her allegations were true, and in August 2026 three solicitors wrote letters about the SLED report on them. He has never been charged. This page sets her words side by side with the record.

On Nov. 12, 2026, Rep. Nancy Mace replied on X to a thread about Brian Banks, a Long Beach, Calif., football star who served five years in prison for a rape he did not commit. She wrote: "That gave me chills. Thank god he got the justice he deserved. Sweet justice." Her post names no one else. This page sets it beside what she wrote about Brian Musgrave, one of the four men she named on the House floor in 2025, and what the court and prosecutors have said since.
Sources: Mace's posts on X, NBC Los Angeles reports on the Banks case (2012 and 2013), the federal court order in Musgrave v. Mace, and the solicitors' letters, all linked below. We read her Nov. 12 post at 5:27 p.m. ET that day.
What she posted
At 3:41 p.m. ET on Nov. 12, @NancyMace posted a reply under a Nov. 11 post by @Benderxxx7 that retells the Banks story (that post):
That gave me chills. Thank god he got the justice he deserved. Sweet justice.
(her post) She did not say which part of his story she meant by "justice," and the post does not mention Musgrave or her own accusations.
What happened to Brian Banks
Banks was a linebacker at Long Beach Polytechnic High School, courted by top colleges including USC, when Wanetta Gibson accused him in 2002 of raping her in a school stairwell. He took a plea bargain that sent him to prison for five years, followed by five years on parole with a GPS monitor on his ankle. Gibson's family received a $1.5 million settlement from the Long Beach school district (NBC Los Angeles, June 7, 2012).
In 2011 Gibson sent Banks a Facebook friend request. He called a private investigator, Freddie Parish, who set up hidden cameras in his office. Gibson came by and said she would help clear Banks but did not want to pay back the settlement. The next day, on camera, Parish asked, "Did he rape you?" and she answered, "No, he did not rape me." Asked whether Banks kidnapped her, she said, "No." A judge overturned Banks's conviction on May 24, 2012. In June 2013 a Los Angeles Superior Court judge ordered Gibson to pay the school district $2.6 million, $1.5 million plus $1.1 million in fees and costs, and Banks signed with the Atlanta Falcons that year (NBC Los Angeles, June 15, 2013).
What she wrote about Musgrave
On Feb. 10, 2025, Mace stood beside a board headed "PREDATORS" on the House floor and read four names into the record, ending with "And Brian Musgrave of Fort Mill, South Carolina." (our dispatch on the speech)
At 7:45 the next morning, after Musgrave denied the accusations, her official account posted:
In Brian Musgrave's denial he said my claims are "baseless" and without a "shred of evidence." He must have missed the part of my speech where I said I "documented" evidence with "metadata." It was also confirmed last night by SLED - there is an active investigation. So, Brian Musgrave, if there is no evidence, there would be no investigation. Hold the line.
(post)
On Aug. 20, 2025, after a federal judge dismissed Musgrave's defamation suit, she posted: "Judge Gergel dismissed Brian Musgrave's baseless defamation suit against me!" (post) Three days later, on Aug. 23, 2025, @RepNancyMace wrote that she had told his attorney she "looked forward to the day when he and his client will be forced to foot the bill for my attorney's fees for the ridiculous false statements told throughout this entire ordeal." (post)
The court and the prosecutors
Musgrave sued Mace for defamation in federal court. On Aug. 20, 2025, U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel substituted the United States for her as the defendant under the Westfall Act and dismissed the case with prejudice. Footnote 1 of the order reads: "The Court offers no opinion concerning the truthfulness or the lack of truthfulness of allegations made by Defendant Mace in her House speech." (order, PDF; case page)
SLED sent its report on her allegations (file 11-23-0312) to Ninth Circuit Solicitor Scarlett Wilson in July 2026. Wilson and two other solicitors wrote about it. Their letters are prosecutors' reviews of SLED's report, not court findings. They were made public on Oct. 14, 2026.
- Wilson, to SLED, Aug. 14, 2026: "Your report offers zero evidence that Mr. Musgrave committed any crime because zero evidence was presented to you." (memo, PDF)
- Fourteenth Circuit Solicitor Duffie Stone, Aug. 18, 2026: "Congresswoman Nancy Mace made many allegations to law enforcement and to the public that have turned out to not be true." (letter, PDF)
- Sixteenth Circuit Solicitor Kevin S. Brackett, Aug. 21, 2026: "Having completed our task diligently, we now know that there is not one speck of evidence that substantiates any of the reckless accusations she made against Mr. Musgrave and that he is completely innocent of these outrageous claims." (letter, PDF)
Musgrave has never been charged. On Oct. 14, 2026, SLED charged the other three men she named; they are presumed innocent (ABC News 4; our dispatch on the letters). His lawyer, Ronnie Richter, told ABC News 4 that his client was "fully vindicated" and that they are "still hoping for an apology from Rep. Mace."
Where the two cases differ, and what the record shows
The two cases are not the same, and nothing here is a finding about anyone. In the Banks case his accuser said on camera that the accusation was not true, and a judge overturned his conviction. In Musgrave's case no court has ruled on whether Mace's allegations were true: the federal order says it "offers no opinion," and the solicitors' letters are prosecutors' reviews, not court findings. Musgrave was never charged.
What the record does show is what Mace has said in public. In February 2025 she wrote, addressing Musgrave by name, that "if there is no evidence, there would be no investigation." On Nov. 12, 2026, she wrote "Thank god he got the justice he deserved" in reply to a thread about a man whose accuser said on camera that the accusation was false. Our archive of her two accounts, which runs through Nov. 2, 2026, has no post naming Musgrave after Aug. 23, 2025, and an X search on Nov. 12 for posts since Aug. 1, 2026 found none.
Since Oct. 12 she has promoted her Speak Your Truth Act, H.R. 10783, in nine X posts. Of the 445 replies X showed under those posts, we counted 37 that asked about people who are falsely accused and 21 more that pointed to her own accusations (our Nov. 4 dispatch).



Read next
November 10, 2026 · Dispatch'If There Is No Evidence, There Would Be No Investigation': Nancy Mace on Brian Musgrave, vs. Scarlett Wilson's Quote Exonerating Him
The morning after she named him on the House floor, Rep. Nancy Mace answered Brian Musgrave's denial on X: 'So, Brian Musgrave, if there is no evidence, there would be no investigation.' His defamation suit was dismissed after the United States was substituted for her, in an order that offers no opinion on whether her allegations were true. Three days later she posted that she looked forward to the day his lawyer 'and his client will be forced to foot the bill for my attorney's fees.' In August 2026, Solicitor Scarlett Wilson wrote to SLED that its report on her allegations 'offers zero evidence that Mr. Musgrave committed any crime because zero evidence was presented to you.' He has never been charged.
October 15, 2026 · Dispatch"She Would Have and Should Have Been Sued Into Bankruptcy": Three South Carolina Prosecutors on Nancy Mace's Accusations Against Brian Musgrave
Three of South Carolina's senior prosecutors reviewed the state investigation of Rep. Nancy Mace's accusations, and each wrote, in a letter now public, that her public accusations against Brian Musgrave lacked evidence. Ninth Circuit Solicitor Scarlett Wilson called them 'spurious claims' resting on 'the lack of even a scintilla of evidence' (Aug. 14, 2026). Fourteenth Circuit Solicitor Duffie Stone wrote that her statements 'branding Brian Musgrave a predator, a rapist, and a human trafficker are shocking' (Aug. 18). Sixteenth Circuit Solicitor Kevin Brackett wrote that 'there is not one speck of evidence' and that, had she not been protected by the Constitution, she 'would have and should have been sued into bankruptcy' (Aug. 21). FITSNews and ABC News 4 published the letters on Oct. 14, 2026. The letters are shown here. Musgrave has always denied the accusations. Mace has not retracted them.
October 17, 2026 · DispatchEXCLUSIVE: Brian Musgrave Speaks to ABC News 4 After Three Prosecutors Clear Him
In an exclusive interview with ABC News 4 (WCIV), Brian Musgrave describes learning from a reporter's text, while driving to buy birdseed, that Rep. Nancy Mace had named him in her February 10, 2025 House floor speech, and what it was like to read the letters of three South Carolina solicitors. Solicitor Kevin Brackett wrote that there is “not one speck of evidence that substantiates any of the reckless accusations she made against Mr. Musgrave and that he is completely innocent of these outrageous claims.” Solicitor Scarlett Wilson wrote of “the lack of even a scintilla of evidence.” Solicitor Duffie Stone wrote that Mace offered “neither evidence nor even suspicions.” Musgrave’s federal suit against Mace was dismissed on August 20, 2025 on immunity grounds, and the court offered no opinion on whether her allegations were true. ABC News 4 reported that Mace has offered no apology. The interview is ABC News 4’s, by Madison Wilber, Oct. 16, 2026.
October 15, 2026 · DispatchSolicitor Scarlett Wilson to SLED: Mace's Credibility "Would Be Thoroughly Undermined"
In an August 14, 2026 Memorandum of Review to SLED, published October 14 by FITSNews and ABC News 4, Ninth Circuit Solicitor Scarlett Wilson wrote that Rep. Nancy Mace's credibility 'would be thoroughly undermined by her false allegations against Mr. Musgrave.' Wilson also wrote that her review offers 'zero evidence' against Brian Musgrave and that Solicitors Duffie Stone and Kevin Brackett 'concur with my assessments.' Musgrave denies Mace's accusations and has not been charged. The letters are prosecutors' reviews, not court findings. Mace has not publicly addressed them.
August 23, 2026 · DispatchMace Won't Talk About Brian Musgrave, and He Isn't Even Under the Gag Order
A year ago this week, a federal judge ended Brian Musgrave's defamation case against Rep. Nancy Mace, not because her 'predator' accusation was found true, but because the court held she was immune. Eighteen months after she named the Fort Mill businessman from the House floor, there is still no criminal charge, no evidence produced, no retraction, and SLED has told him he is not a target. Musgrave was never a party to the case Mace is gagged in, and his own case is closed, so nothing bars her from answering for the accusation. She simply does not.
October 17, 2026 · DispatchSLED Checked 26 of Mace's Allegations. The Prosecutor Called Her Description of the Video 'Inaccurate, if Not False.'
SLED's 147-page report looked at 26 allegations Rep. Nancy Mace made against four men on the House floor. The Post and Courier got the report and the prosecutor's memo through an open records request. Solicitor Scarlett Wilson wrote that the video Mace described shows the opposite of what she said, calling her description 'inaccurate, if not false'. On a separate claim, four witnesses told SLED the camera she called hidden in Bryant's condo was in plain view. SLED also found no child sexual abuse images. All four men named by Mace issued strong denials. Mace did not respond to the paper.